The Life of a Showgirl: Gloriously Misunderstood, by Fans and Taylor Swift Alike

Taylor Swift’s long-awaited The Life of a Showgirl arrived at the beginning of this month with some big promises: glitz, storytelling, and pop princess energy. However, since its release, it’s been met with confusion, criticism, and a wave of lukewarm reviews from fans and the general public alike.

Amongst all this noise, it’s managed to hit 4 million sales in the US in its first week, marking the biggest album debut on the Billboard Hot 200 in modern history. So, what’s the real problem with The Life of a Showgirl, and why, for the first time in a while, are Swifties divided?

Where did TLOAS go wrong?

Here’s the real qualm: We’ve been spoiled.

We’ve had poetry gifted to us in the form of folklore, evermore, and 2024’s The Tortured Poets Department. As I sit here with “How Did It End?” playing, I wonder: Are we holding Taylor Swift to an impossible standard?

TLOAS isn’t a bad album. In fact, parts of it sparkle. At a first listen, I assumed “Father Figure” was a brilliant ironic jab at critics who accuse her of controlling her younger protégés - truly reminiscent of Blank Space. Since digesting the lyrics, it’s revealed itself as a fantastic commentary on her fallout with Scott Borchetta, and her triumph over him by winning back her masters. 

The first three tracks are sonically fun. “Ruin the Friendship” has beautiful storytelling that transported me back to the likes of “Seven,” “The Bolter,” and “Forever Winter.” Lyrically, however, this album is winning no awards for me - but could we say the same if another artist had released it? Why does the world expect so much from Taylor Swift?

Because she has consistently proven herself to be the best.

Taylor Swift’s long, decorated history of Grammys

Taylor has won 14 Grammys in total. That’s an insane number, and most artists dream of winning just one. Her 4 Album Of The Year winners have all been genre-defying, era-building records with no doubt of their musical supremacy. 

Fearless showed us how an 18-year-old Country singer could break into mainstream charts by appealing to other young girls. 1989 became the most awarded pop album ever. folklore was a quiet masterpiece of introspection. Midnights was a polished concept album that landed during the record-breaking Eras Tour. To me, TLOAS doesn’t sit with these masterpieces that, in many ways, were the first of their kind. True cultural resets, if you will.

Didn't we just do this with The Tortured Poets Department?

It’s worth remembering that The Tortured Poets Department also received early criticism when it was first released in April 2024. I see TTPD as a long stream of consciousness, not necessarily meant to have peaks or radio-ready hits (although I would have picked any other song as its lead single). When you start to see the artist's vision, the music makes more sense. It took most people about a week to realize that; With TLOAS, I’m still struggling to see what Taylor, Max Martin, and Shellback saw. Where’s the central spine that binds it all together like the folklore love triangle or Midnights late-night dreamscape? 

On the other hand, we can’t ignore the huge commercial success TLOAS has been in comparison with TTPD. Its upbeat, fun nature has definitely won over every radio station, which TTPD just couldn’t compete with.

TLOAS embraces catchy hooks and energetic production that showcase Swift's continued mastery of the pop format. Even as fans debate its lyrical depth, it’s worth recognizing that TLOAS succeeds in areas where TTPD intentionally did not, particularly in terms of accessibility, momentum, and traditional pop structure.

‍

The real problem

Despite all of this, one of the biggest mistakes with this album had nothing to do with the music, the lyrics, or the producers. It was actually all to do with the marketing. 

In the form of photoshoots, interviews, and an intriguing tracklist, we were sold a diamond dream. 

But the album itself doesn’t match that aesthetic. It’s not a Showgirl record: not thematically, not lyrically, and not emotionally. If this album had come wrapped in Lover-style pastels or 1989 minimalism, maybe the expectations would have been better aligned. The problem is, the marketing doesn’t match the music. A Showgirl, by definition, commands attention: she's dazzling, theatrical, unapologetically bold. But much of this album feels emotionally reserved and introspective, with lyrics that often circle around internal conflict, insecurity, and self-doubt rather than celebration or performance. The production is slick, but not particularly flamboyant or playful; there are few moments that feel genuinely joyful or extravagant in the way the Showgirl branding suggests. Instead of sparkle, we get a kind of glossy melancholy which is polished, but subdued. That mismatch creates a sense of dissonance: the album was sold as a spectacle, but much of what we’re hearing is closer to self-reflection than show-stopping confidence.

I have spent my life defending Taylor Swift because she truly speaks to me in a way that very few artists do. I’ll never hate her, and I’ll never stop listening to her. Her “moment” hasn’t passed and I hate that sexist stereotype of female pop icons fighting for the limelight when they can all shine together at once. She just hasn’t hit the mark with this album, but one miss doesn’t undo a legacy of brilliance, or mean she can ever reach those highs again.

If you enjoyed this article, sign up to our newsletter and follow us on Instagram and LinkedIn to stay up to date with Gen Admission 🎶